Skip to content

Coming soon

A secret ballot your leadership does not run itself.

The sealed ballot box, in 3 shares

Sample resultYes131No79Rejected4

The ballot box is sealed. No share is here: nobody can read anything.

Try it: bring 2 shares.

A union's executive, an association's board of directors: Camarade will run the vote in their place, as a third party. The vote will open and close by itself, at the time written down. Camarade will not be able to read the ballot box alone: its key will be split in 3 shares, and it will take 2.

Not available yet. No real vote before a penetration test by an independent firm and the opinion of a labour lawyer.

The principle, in 4 points.

A union or an association is not electing a head of state. It needs a simple vote, run by someone other than the people with a stake in the result.

  • Camarade runs the vote, not the people in charge.

    Your organization prepares and requests. Camarade accepts, schedules, runs, closes and publishes. Your leadership will not be able to open, close or extend the vote, or see anything before publication.

  • Camarade cannot read the ballot box alone.

    Each ballot will be encrypted on the voter's own device. The ballot box key will be split in 3 shares: the returning officer, a scrutineer, Camarade. It will take 2.

  • Who voted and what was voted never meet.

    They are 2 separate records. No table, no column and no log will link a person to a ballot. The record will keep neither the time, nor the originating address, nor the device of a vote.

  • Everything Camarade does is written down.

    Every action will go into a log where each line carries the fingerprint of the one before. Your returning officer will be able to read it at any time.

What will protect your vote.

No big words: specific protections, each of which the penetration test will have to try before the first vote.

Established voting services have years of penetration tests and attestations that Camarade does not have yet. That is why the module stays closed until then.

What we aim for: Nobody sees a result before the close, not even Camarade.
What will make it true: Ballots encrypted in the browser; a key in 3 shares, 2 required, Camarade holds only one; no share is accepted and the ballot box is handed to nobody before the close.
What we aim for: The people in charge do not run their own vote.
What will make it true: No function for the organization to open, close or read the vote; once the voters list is frozen, even a corrected address needs the returning officer's approval.
What we aim for: Each voter checks that their ballot is in the box that was counted.
What will make it true: A receipt given at the vote; the list of receipts can be read once the result is published, and until the ballots are destroyed.
What we aim for: The ballot box does not change between the close and the count.
What will make it true: The fingerprint of the closed box is emailed to the returning officer, the scrutineers and the observers before the box is opened, and goes into the signed record; it is recomputed from the ballots at the count and at the recount.
What we aim for: The result does not rest on Camarade's server alone.
What will make it true: The election officials can recount the ballot box themselves: after the close, the returning officer and the scrutineer, together, download the closed box and recount it in their browser with their 2 shares, without Camarade. A discrepancy freezes the vote and stops any automatic publication.
What we aim for: The organization reads everything Camarade did.
What will make it true: A chained log of the vote, readable by the returning officer at any time; its state at the close is emailed with the ballot box fingerprint and goes into the signed record: a rewritten log would no longer match.
What we aim for: At Camarade, no sensitive action and no setting change by one person alone, as soon as its team running votes has 2 people.
What will make it true: The 2-person rule, enforced by the database; one person cannot switch it off alone; every setting change is written in a log. While the team has only one person, that person acts alone, and the signed record says so.
What we aim for: The election officials do nothing alone either.
What will make it true: Admitting a voter once the list is frozen, running the voting table, correcting the paper count: each time 2 different roles, with a trace, and the counts go into the signed record.
What we aim for: Nobody is told who voted, or when.
What will make it true: No function returns the list of who voted or who did not; Camarade keeps neither the time, nor the originating address, nor the device of a vote; turnout is rounded, every 2 hours, by a counter with no names.
What we aim for: Data stays in Quebec, and ballots are destroyed.
What will make it true: Hosting in the Montreal region; destruction at the end of the retention period, with a written record.

How it goes, from the question to the signed record.

Each step says who acts. After the request, the people in charge touch nothing.

  1. Prepare

    The organization

    The kind of vote, the question and the choices, the voting period, the voters list, the roles: returning officer, scrutineers, observers.

  2. Agree and request

    The organization, then Camarade

    The vote agreement states exactly what the organization asks for and what Camarade will do. Camarade accepts, with 2 people, or sends it back with a reason. When all goes well, that is the only action taken by a person at Camarade. The voters list is frozen.

  3. Seal the ballot box

    The returning officer

    In their browser, the ballot box key is made and split in 3 shares. A test ballot is encrypted, then opened with 2 shares, to prove that everything works.

  4. Vote

    The voters

    Voting opens on time, by itself. Each voter opens their personal link, identifies themselves, chooses, confirms and gets a receipt. One vote, final. Reminders go to everyone, never only to those who have not voted.

  5. Close, count, recount

    The election officials and Camarade

    Voting closes on time, never earlier. The fingerprint of the ballot box is emailed right away. As soon as the returning officer (or the scrutineer) brings their share, 2 shares of the key open the box; ballots are shuffled, counted, and only the result is written. The returning officer and the scrutineer can then recount the box together, in their browser, without Camarade.

  6. Publish, keep, destroy

    Camarade

    The record of the vote is signed in 2 parts, the election officials then Camarade, and the result is published; that is when the list of receipts can be read. If the election officials do not sign, Camarade can publish after a delay, with 2 people, with a note that says so. Ballots and the turnout record are kept at least 365 days, then destroyed, with a written record.

The voters list, read 3 times before it is frozen.

A mistyped address is a person who loses their vote. So the database reads the list 3 times, with no artificial intelligence. It suggests a correction; it never applies one by itself.

  1. 1. The formAn incomplete name, an invisible character copied from a spreadsheet, the same person twice, the same address for 2 people.
  2. 2. The typosA comma for a period, a domain 1 or 2 letters away from a common one, an ending that does not exist.
  3. 3. The real testA test email, with no voting link, goes to every voter. The report says whether it was delivered, delayed, or bounced.

Then 2 people, by hand: the administrator confirms the list, and the returning officer attests to it. If the list changes, everything is done again.

What this check does not tell: that a delivered address belongs to the right person, or that a delivered email was read. The kiosk and paper stay open to anyone who received nothing.

Everything happens by itself, at the time written down.

Camarade runs the vote by its rules rather than by one person's actions. Every automatic action is written in the log, and the signed record gives the count.

What happens by itself

  • The notice of vote, to the whole list
  • The opening, and the voting links
  • Reminders: 3 at most, always to everyone
  • The close, then the ballot box fingerprint sent out and the close announced to everyone on the list
  • The count, as soon as the returning officer brings their share
  • Publication, once the record is signed
  • Destruction, at the end of the retention period

What stays with a person

  • Preparing, correcting and confirming the listThe organization's administrator
  • Attesting to the list, sealing the box, bringing a share, recounting, signing the recordThe returning officer, the scrutineer
  • Ruling on a challenged voter (2 roles), deciding on an extension, counting paper ballotsThe election officials
  • Accepting the request, or sending it backCamarade, with 2 people

By accepting the vote, the 2 people at Camarade authorize in advance that its share be used for the count. An incident or a challenge withdraws that authorization: the 2-person action is required again.

3 ways to vote, one record so that nobody votes twice.

  • OnlineWith a personal link.
  • In personAt a kiosk run by 2 election officials.
  • On paper

Voters without email will get their access by letter, or vote in person.

Who it is for.

Unions first: that is Camarade's trade. And any organization whose members vote, because the principle is the same everywhere: the people in charge do not run their own vote.

  • A union

    Who votes: The members

    Who does not run the vote: The executive

  • An association, a not-for-profit

    Who votes: The members, at the general meeting

    Who does not run the vote: The board of directors

  • A co-operative

    Who votes: The members, one vote each

    Who does not run the vote: The board of directors

  • A student association

    Who votes: The student members

    Who does not run the vote: The executive or the council

Not condominiums, for now. At a meeting of co-owners, votes are counted by each owner's share, often by proxy. Camarade's ballot counts one vote per person.

Your union has its Office

The vote will be prepared in the Office, with the voters list drawn from your directory. Subscribing unions will get a reduced price.

One vote at a time, no subscription

Any organization will be able to request a single vote, without being a Camarade customer. It will get a Ballot Office: just what it takes to prepare, follow and read the signed record, readable until the end of the retention period.

Which votes

First

  • Elections, for one or more positions: executive, board of directors, committee
  • Dues
  • Changes to the constitution or bylaws
  • Other decisions of a meeting: a question, some choices

Later

  • Strike votes
  • Ratification votes

After the penetration test and the lawyer's opinion.

Not for now

  • Weighted votes: ownership shares, units
  • Proxies
  • Ranked or multi-round voting
  • Nominations
  • Live voting during a meeting

One person, one vote, over a period set in advance. And at least 10 voters: below that, secrecy does not hold.

The limits, stated plainly.

Remote voting has limits, and so does ours. Better to read them here than after the fact.

  • It does not protect a person who is watched or paid at home, or an infected device.

    Voting in person stays available for that.

  • Without a second piece of identification, a person who reads a voter's mailbox can vote in their place.

    That second piece (an employee number or a date of birth) will be required for strike and ratification votes; elsewhere the organization chooses, and the signed record says when a vote had none. Even with it, a co-worker or a relative often knows that information.

  • Whoever can change Camarade's code and put it online can do anything.

    No database rule changes that. The safeguards lie elsewhere: who deploys, how many people it takes, what review; and the recount by the election officials, which shows a false count, but not a ballot diverted before it was encrypted.

  • Someone reading the database continuously during the vote could match a person voting with a ballot arriving.

    Camarade keeps neither the time nor the address of a vote, which closes the shortest path. What remains is the order of writes, the backups and the hosting provider's logs; the penetration test will look at this point first.

  • Camarade, together with one of the organization's shares, can open the ballot box.

    That is the count, after the close only. It is also what collusion between a person at Camarade and the returning officer or the scrutineer would make possible.

  • The returning officer and the scrutineer, together, can open the ballot box without Camarade.

    That is the recount. They read the total, after the close only, never who voted what. In a very small vote, or if every vote goes to the same choice, the total already tells how each person voted: the signed record flags it.

  • 2 election officials acting together can admit a person who has no right to vote, or vote in person in place of someone who is absent.

    It is written down, with both names and the counts in the signed record; that does not prevent it. The safeguard is the observer in the room.

  • The administrator and the returning officer acting together can point a voter's link to another address before the opening.

    A “corrected” address is counted in the signed record.

  • Camarade's team is small: while a single person runs the votes, that person acts alone.

    It is written in the settings log and in the signed record; that prevents nothing. And 2 people at Camarade acting together can do everything Camarade can.

  • If the election officials do not sign the record, Camarade will still be able to publish the result, after a delay.

    With 2 people, and with the note “record not signed by the election officials”, which everyone will see.

  • An encrypted ballot cannot be checked when it arrives.

    If it is malformed, it is counted as “rejected” at the count, like a spoiled paper ballot.

  • A vote that was started but whose ballot never arrives stays without a ballot.

    A browser closed at the wrong moment, for example. A new link cannot pick it up, because nothing links a person to a ballot; it is counted in the gap shown in the signed record.

  • The recount does not see a ballot box replaced as a whole.

    The fingerprint received by email at the close is what would show it: it is there to be compared.

  • No service can promise that an email reaches an inbox.

    Hence the test mailing a few days ahead, resending the link, the letter and the kiosk.

  • Nothing has been tested by an independent firm yet.

    That is why the module stays closed.

  • What your constitution or bylaws allow, and what the law requires for each kind of vote, is for your organization and a legal opinion.

    Camarade does not decide for you.

Plain questions.

When will secret ballots be available?

No date. The module will stay closed until there has been a penetration test by an independent firm and the opinion of a labour lawyer.

Is it only for unions?

No. Unions first, but the same ballot will serve an association's general meeting, the election of a board of directors, a co-operative or a student association, one vote at a time. It counts one vote per person: no weighted votes and no proxies, which rules out condominiums for now.

Who will be able to see my vote?

Nobody while the ballot box is closed. At the count, ballots are opened shuffled, without names, and only the result is written. Nothing links a person to their ballot.

Will Camarade be able to read the ballot box?

Not alone: it will hold only one share of the key out of 3, and it takes 2. With one of the organization's shares, yes: that is the count, after the close. We also say, above, what collusion would make possible.

Will the election officials be able to recount by themselves?

Yes. After the close, the returning officer and the scrutineer will be able, together, to download the closed ballot box and recount it in their browser with their 2 shares, without Camarade. If their count differs from the server's, the vote is frozen and nothing is published automatically. They read the total, never who voted what.

Will the leadership know who voted?

No. No function will return the list of who voted or who did not. The returning officer will only see turnout rounded to the nearest 10, updated every 2 hours.

Will Camarade know when I voted, and from where?

No. The record will keep your name, the vote and the way you voted (online, in person, on paper). It will keep neither the time, nor the originating address, nor the device. The hosting provider keeps its own technical logs: that is one of the limits stated above.

How do I check that my ballot was counted?

You will get a receipt when you vote. Once the result is published, the list of receipts can be read: if yours is on it, your ballot is in the box that was counted. The receipt does not show your choice.

What will be automatic?

The notice of vote, the opening, the reminders, the close, sending the ballot box fingerprint, the count as soon as the returning officer brings their share, then publication once the record is signed. A person at Camarade acts only to accept the request, with 2 people, and if there is an incident.

What if the site goes down during the vote?

The returning officer will be able to decide on an extension, and all voters will be told. A vote is never shortened.

Why not a simple survey?

A survey consults; it does not decide. A secret ballot requires that nobody sees the choices, that nobody closes early, and that each voter can check that their ballot was counted.

Is it valid for a strike vote?

Camarade will not run strike votes or ratification votes at first. For any kind of vote, the answer depends on your bylaws and on a legal opinion.

Will we need a Camarade subscription?

No. A union, an association or another organization will be able to request a single vote. Subscribing unions will get a reduced price. Prices are not set.

Coming soon

Want to hear when it is ready?

Send us a note. A real person from Camarade will answer, and will write again when secret ballots open.

Write to Camarade

The button opens an email to [email protected]. This page has no form.